A federal judge in Manhattan acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud and related charges on November 16, 2026, ruling that prosecutors failed to show any material misrepresentation in a 2023 Ethereum exploit they said took $25 million from other traders in about 12 seconds.
District Judge Jessica Clarke said the question was not whether the strategy was improper or unethical, but whether it constituted wire fraud. The ruling comes a year after a jury deadlocked on November 7, 2025.
Crypto heist case turns on proof of misrepresentation
Prosecutors alleged that the brothers exploited a software vulnerability to execute a rapid bait-and-switch operation in April 2023.
Their account described a plan to lure automated trading bots into transactions that would drain other cryptocurrency traders’ accounts. Clarke, however, found that the evidence presented at trial did not show the brothers made material misrepresentations when carrying out the transactions.
“The question before the court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos’ conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes,” Clarke said.
She then defined the narrower issue before her: whether the trial evidence, viewed in the government’s favour, could support convictions for wire fraud and related offences.
That distinction was decisive in the crypto heist case. The alleged use of a software bug, and the amount of money involved, did not substitute for evidence establishing the elements of the charges.
The acquittal therefore should not be interpreted as a general ruling that exploiting software vulnerabilities is always lawful. Clarke assessed the transactions and evidence presented in this particular prosecution.
Prosecutors alleged months of planning around Ethereum transactions
The crypto heist case concerned the process used to validate transactions for inclusion on Ethereum’s blockchain.
Prosecutors said the brothers spent months planning to manipulate and tamper with those protocols. Their alleged method exploited a vulnerability in MEV-Boost, software used by most Ethereum validators, according to the prosecution’s account.
Validators help check transactions before they are added to the blockchain, the public ledger recording network activity. Prosecutors argued that the brothers interfered with that process to execute their trading scheme.
The alleged transfer of $25 million took approximately 12 seconds, although investigators described a much longer period of preparation leading up to it.
Defense lawyers disputed the prosecution’s characterisation, maintaining that the brothers had executed a legitimate strategy. The disagreement in the crypto heist case consequently extended beyond how the software worked to whether the transactions involved criminal deception.
Clarke concluded that the transactions contained no misrepresentations. She also noted that they “were not placed on a regulated market with rules prohibiting this conduct.”
Crypto heist case follows indictment and deadlocked jury
The brothers were indicted in May 2024, more than a year after the April 2023 transactions.
Prosecutors characterised the alleged scheme as a type of fraud that had not previously been prosecuted federally. That made the proceedings a test of how existing fraud charges applied to the particular trading conduct at issue.
A jury subsequently failed to reach a verdict, leaving the charges unresolved until Clarke’s decision.
In explaining the standard she applied, the judge said the issue was “whether the evidence at trial, construed in a light most favorable to the government, could support wire fraud and related convictions in this case.”
Her ruling brought the crypto heist case to an acquittal based on the insufficiency she identified in the prosecution’s evidence. It was not a jury finding that resolved every factual disagreement between the parties.
The source does not describe a new trial or further proceedings following the decision.
Brothers’ technical backgrounds featured in prosecution’s account
Both defendants studied at MIT, where prosecutors said they developed skills later used in their trading strategy.
According to media reports cited in the account, Anton earned a bachelor’s degree in computer science and engineering in 2024. James obtained a similar degree in 2019 and a master’s degree in aeronautics in 2021.
Their technical expertise formed part of the prosecution’s explanation of how the alleged operation was possible. But the outcome of the crypto heist case depended on proof of fraud, rather than the sophistication of the participants.
Lawyers for the brothers had no immediate comment following the ruling. A spokesperson for U.S. Attorney James McDonald, whose office brought the prosecution, declined to comment.
The crypto heist case ultimately ended with Clarke finding a gap between the government’s allegations and the evidence required for conviction. Her decision leaves a specific conclusion: the prosecution did not establish the material misrepresentations necessary to sustain the charged wire fraud and related offences.