An Abu Dhabi court has granted Binance a $6.5 billion worldwide freezing order to help it pursue the hackers behind its $6.3 billion theft on Oct. 29, and to track the stolen crypto across a “living list” of 26,000 wallet addresses.
The Abu Dhabi Global Market Courts also allowed Binance to serve legal orders through the blockchain, as reported by Bitcoin.com News, citing Bloomberg.
How the Binance hack order follows funds across wallets
By the time Binance sought the injunction, its lawyers had identified 26,000 wallet addresses linked to the stolen assets. A fixed inventory would tell exchanges and stablecoin issuers where investigators had already traced the money. Its value would diminish each time funds moved to an address outside the original set.
Binance’s lawyers described the addresses as a “living list.” As investigators trace proceeds from the Binance hack to another wallet, they can update the list. The court also allowed its orders to be served through the blockchain, giving investigators a way to deliver legal notice even while the identities of the people behind the transfers remain unknown.
The FBI has attributed the Binance hack to TraderTraitor, a group it links to North Korea. That attribution identifies the group the bureau believes was responsible. The Abu Dhabi proceedings address a separate question of immediate importance to the exchange and to firms holding the assets: where the money went after it left Binance.
Court targets specific assets held by third parties
Alongside the worldwide freezing order, the court granted proprietary injunctions and delivery-up orders covering particular assets. Some of those assets are in the hands of parties Binance has not accused of wrongdoing. That matters in the Binance hack case because an exchange or another intermediary may hold funds that investigators have traced long after the original theft.
The orders give Binance a way to pursue those specific holdings as well as the perpetrators. For a firm receiving notice, the wallet list identifies where investigators have traced funds. Whether the firm can prevent a further transfer depends in part on what it holds. Stablecoin issuers, for example, have already been able to block the movement of some of the tokens identified in the investigation.
“We will continue using every lawful tool available to trace, freeze, and recover stolen assets,” said Dugan Bliss, Binance’s deputy general counsel.
What the $2.85 billion figure measures
Blockchain analytics firm Elliptic verified that about $2.85 billion linked to the Binance hack had been frozen or seized. Most of that sum consisted of stablecoins whose issuers could block transfers. Elliptic’s figure provides a measure of how much money investigators and industry participants had managed to immobilize by the time of the report.
The larger dollar amounts in the Binance hack case answer different questions. The estimated $6.3 billion measures the value of the cryptocurrency stolen on Oct. 29. The $6.5 billion describes the scope of the Abu Dhabi injunction. Neither figure establishes how much cryptocurrency has been returned to the exchange, and even the verified $2.85 billion includes funds that are still frozen.
In a separate US action, the Justice Department obtained court authorization to seize or restrain more than $1.2 billion connected to the Binance hack. The reported figures do not establish how much of the US amount overlaps with the assets Elliptic counted. Adding the two amounts would therefore give an unreliable picture of the recovery effort.
Binance says it has replenished customer assets
Binance said it had replaced the affected customer assets and that users absorbed no losses from the Binance hack. That resolves a different issue for account holders than the one before the Abu Dhabi court. Customers can have their balances restored by the exchange while Binance continues to pursue the parties holding the stolen cryptocurrency.
The practical test for the court’s approach is whether an updated address reaches an issuer or exchange while it can still act on the funds. The 26,000 addresses show the scale of the tracing work already undertaken. How much of the frozen cryptocurrency Binance ultimately recovers will give a clearer indication of what that work achieved.